Report this comment
  • "The misery these THUGS cause !
    They laugh at our soft system knowing that if caught they just get a
    ' smack on the wrist ' is an insult to everybody hurt who has been through that sort of situation...
    It makes you aware that going out especially at night, you can't turn your back anymore wondering if your next ?
    I wonder if it happened to say,, a Politian or his/her family that we would see some sort of action ?
    For example...
    When the NHS failed MP Anne Clwyd's husband we soon heard of her having a go at the system !"
  • This field is mandatory
  • This field is mandatory
  • Please note we will not accept reports with HTML tags or URLs in them.

  • Enter the above word in the box below

Outraged Cwmbran mum in plea for tougher penalties

First published in News

THE mother of a man who is still suffering after an ammonia attack four years ago has called for harsher sentences and stricter licence conditions for those whose crimes maim for life.

Tracey Brown, whose son Dorian Neale had ammonia thrown in his eyes while out in Newport city centre in August 2010, spoke out after reading the Argus’ story about Chris Collins, a former professional archer who lost an eye in a vicious attack by two strangers on New Year’s Day.

Mr Collins’ attackers, a 15-year-old who cannot be named, and 18-year-old Jay Lloyd, of Cedar Drive, Rogerstone, received a six-month-referral order and three years behind bars respectively.

Earlier this month Mr Collins slammed the sentences as “a joke” and “a kick in the guts”, while the judge sentencing Lloyd criticised the Crown Prosecution Service for bringing a charge which limited his sentencing powers.

Mr Neale was out in Newport city centre four years ago when a 23-year-old squirted ammonia into his eyes and punched him.

Blinded and separated from his friends, Mr Neale was found by police near Newport railway station and screamed with pain as his eyes were washed out in hospital.

The forklift truck driver, now 31, was later diagnosed with scarred corneas and still visits Newport’s Royal Gwent for eye drops to dilate his pupils and help him see.

His attacker, who pleaded guilty to two counts of actual bodily harm on the day his trial was due to start, was sentenced to two years behind bars in 2012, a sentence which Mrs Brown said made her feel “badly let down”.

Mr Neale did not wish to speak to the Argus but Mrs Brown said he supported her comments.

“Dorian lost his sight for a few months and was in agony,” said the mum-of-five from Cwmbran.

“I looked after him, guided him around the house and put eye drops in for him every hour. It was so painful for him sometimes I used to go into the next room and just cry.

“[The sentence his attacker received] makes me really angry,” she said, adding that she agreed such offenders should be given tougher sentences and stricter licence conditions.

“My heart goes out to Mr Collins, where is the justice? You are never the same and it has a long-term effect on the family.

“It is making a mockery of [the justice system], giving them the right to inflict this and get away with it. Police are powerless on breaches. People get more for damaging property. It’s disheartening to the victims.”

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree