Report this comment
  • "Neagle does not speak for ALL residents pf Varteg, and she may come to learn that there is a current call by a number of us to have that school she was so concerned about made to move from our locality
    The amount of in coming traffic it generates twice per day, possibly far out weighs the potential dust and fumes she and others were moaning about, should the project go ahead.

    The decision by Sargent was perverse and has simply delayed the job, but I wonder what he had to do with the planning approval of a far more nuisance project, the race track in B Gwent, a project that if it goes ahead will create as much if not more dust and atmospheric pollution and on a continuing and perpetual basis for the nearby residents and places of business, amongst which are food processors.

    The whole lot stinks of collusion between the Assembly, it's ministers and our never so present Barry residing AM.

    She's says she is dismayed and disappointed, well welcome to the club dear Lynn, AND WE LIVE HERE, how do you think many in Varteg feel?
    We were hoping to see the project through to completion, whilst you live thirty odd miles away and would not be inconvenienced, except by the moaning lot who send their kids to the dratted pollution generating, and unwelcome Ysgol your mates in TCBC dumped on us
    I wonder what else SARGENT WILL HAVE UP HIS SLEEVE WHEN THE FURTHER APPEAL LANDS ON THE TABLE, I wonder what else you will be talking to him about in your hideaway Assembly building, what more secret deals will you both cook up to thwart Glamorgan Power and those of us that support the project?

    And today there is news that a further mobile unit is to be placed in the school grounds to accommodate another 35 pupils. This will add yet more traffic attending twice a day thereby increasing the amount of noise, road dust and pollution into the air from burning fuels.

    What traffic is attending these days generates far more pollution than the proposed opencast will. Adding more pupils with their attendant transports will not of course be taken in to consideration by all those who oppose the project.

    Retarded thinking without doubt."
  • This field is mandatory
  • This field is mandatory
  • Please note we will not accept reports with HTML tags or URLs in them.


  • Enter the above word in the box below

Varteg mine plan back before council

A CONTROVERSIAL planning application to mine 256,000 tonnes of coal in the Varteg looks like it could be back before Torfaen Councillors.

Just four months after the plan were refused by Welsh minister Carl Sargeant, the applicant, Glamorgan Power Company Ltd, has informed Torfaen council that it is considering submitting a new planning application.

A seminar was called on Monday to update councillors about the pre-planning application enquiry, and concerned residents and representatives of the school, Ysgol Bryn Onnen, packed into the public gallery.

Leading the seminar was Chief Planning and Public Protection Officer at Torfaen Council, Duncan Smith.

He said that this type of enquiry was common practice, but said that “as it's on a controversial application, we thought it only right to let you know.”

He recapped that Torfaen Council refused the application in 2011 due to its proximity to houses, this led to an inquiry in 2012, and the then minister John Griffiths sent a letter stating he was minded to allow it.

Then in November 2013, the minister for housing and regeneration, Mr Sargeant, refused to grant outline planning permission for the land reclamation and coal recovery scheme at Varteg Hill.

In January this year, the company approached the council advising that it is considering a new planning application and they want to work with Torfaen council to identify feasible options.

Mr Smith explained that the minister thought the application was ‘environmentally acceptable’, despite school children being taught only 120 metres from the proposed mine and houses being within 500 metres.

The minister, however, did not accept that the benefits of the scheme justified working within 500m of the settlement, and since no evaluation of alternative options had been carried out, it could not be concluded that the proposed development was the most effective solution.

Another reason for refusal was in regard to the unilateral undertaking, and the minister remained concerned that there was insufficient detail to satisfy him that funding would be available to complete the restoration should the developer fail to do so.

So the company is now seeking to address these points, but Mr Smith said there has not been an application received yet.

Torfaen AM, Lynne Neagle, said: “Local residents have spent years in a state of limbo with the threat of this development hanging over their heads – it is just not acceptable.

“Of course we’ll have to await the detail, but what I do know, is that overwhelmingly people in Varteg simply don’t want this on their doorstep.

“ Working with local residents and campaigners, I will do everything I can to see these latest proposals defeated - Glamorgan Power are facing the fight of their lives.”

Local Businesses

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree